John Gower Design

  • Built Projects
  • Stock Plan Catalogue
  • About
  • Resources
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

To Fly, or Not To Fly?

October 16, 2019 By Marusha 3 Comments

Last week I attended a memorial service for an old friend in the Slocan Valley. As many of you know, I’ve maintained a strong anti-flying stance for years in order to minimize my CO2 footprint. As usual, I intended to drive to the service, thinking this to be the most carbon-responsible means of travel.

However, my curiosity got the better of me and I decided to test that assumption. To calculate the relative carbon costs of driving versus other options, I went to CarbonFootprint.com, a popular UK-based site (https://www.carbonfootprint.com/ ). There were additional factors to consider: driving all the way to my destination would entail a ferry ride in both directions, and flying would include the rental of a hybrid car at the other end.

To my surprise, flying turned out to be the preferred option. A round-trip flight from Comox to Vancouver to Cranbrook, with a car rental during my visit, would result in a total carbon cost of 0.32 tonnes (based on the average number of passengers occupying those flights). A round-trip in my car, including the ferry ride both ways, would cost 0.52 tonnes (based on myself as sole occupant of the vehicle, which was the case; an additional passenger would cut our individual footprints by half).

So on this occasion, I broke with my usual custom and flew. This resulted in quite a discussion back at the office, and we decided to do some further calculations to see what it would cost Marusha and her spouse to visit family in Toronto (a round-trip of 9370 km) using all the available options. Again, each one would include a ferry trip each way. The results, from most to least carbon-costly, were as follows:

By bus, return trip: 2.74 tonnes of CO2 (1.37 tonnes per person in a regular-sized coach)

Driving: 2.06 tonnes (1.03 tonnes per person in a 2008 Toyota Yaris)

Flying: 1.56 tonnes (0.78 tonnes per person)

By rail: 0.78 tonnes (0.39 tonnes per person)

 

The takeaway from all this is that the no-fly position isn’t always black and white, and it may actually make more sense to fly in some circumstances. It’s also clear that going solo is far from optimal in any case, and that rail travel is a much-undervalued (and undeveloped) choice in this country.

 

It’s important to use the available tools to inform our decisions when planning to travel, and to try to limit the number of unnecessary trips we make in a year. This involves some hard questions – how often do we need to see family or friends? Is our presence at that cross-Atlantic destination wedding really important? What about the costs and benefits of voluntourism? As always, I welcome your comments and insights!

 

Filed Under: Blog, Energy Efficiency, Future-Proofing, Miscellany, Sustainable Lifestyles

Comments

  1. Derek Andrews says

    October 16, 2019 at 10:50 pm

    Hi John
    Not sure if bus or rail options are even available in your situation.
    My question, is the rail option based on passenger rail costs? If so how many per train. Given the current ridiculously high cost of rail travel I am not sure it is a viable option.

    Reply
    • John Gower says

      October 30, 2019 at 8:43 pm

      Can’t disagree with the fact that rail is ridiculously expensive Derek. It’s been made into a tourist experience rather than an everyday mode of transport. The online calculator that I used is based in the UK, and while it uses an average occupancy per mode of travel, this may be based more on a European model. And in many cases, the trains there are electric. So in fact, the carbon cost of rail travel in North America, per passenger, may possibly be higher.

      Reply
  2. dick says

    October 17, 2019 at 3:25 pm

    An electric car would reduce the footprint but not going would have the greatest effect. We may have to drop some cultural norms to survive our next few decades.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Clients Say…

Bud and I wanted to thank you for the plans for our wonderful new home. It was a pleasure to work with you. I was concerned that we might have a difficult time working together with your being so far away. I must admit you made the process very easy. You seem to have a knack for taking what I saw in my mind and making it happen, even better than I could see it.
Bud and Sandy H.Idaho
View all testimonials
Your building plans worked fine for us and there were no issues of any size… We moved in here in Dec.2013 and find the house well laid out and easy to live in. Our dealings with your company were straight forward and presented no problems. All in all a good choice for us.
HelmutChilliwack, BC
View all testimonials
Every time someone asks me about the design for our house, I tell them how great you were to work with and how you took my attempts to change things and made them happen on paper. Thanks so much!
Constance and Lee
View all testimonials
Thank you John. It has been a pleasure working (by phone) with you! We do appreciate the manner in which you listen – we truly feel that our ideas have been incorporated.
Jed and Helen D.Nelson, BC
View all testimonials
We hired John Gower Design to design an energy efficient Arts & Crafts style home for us. Working with John was an enjoyable and productive experience. He took our ideas and made them a reality. We found John’s strengths to be his sense of space and proportion and his willingness to listen to our ideas. We have lived in the house for two years and are continually amazed at how well the house works and its comfort and beauty.
Ross N.Victoria, BC
View all testimonials
We’ve been living in it for a year now and are really pleased with the design and the final product. I can’t thank you enough for the extra work you did designing the downstairs living space. It is a perfect floor plan and very roomy. I can’t believe all that we are able to fit in there.  We hope that you are still designing houses when we build our next house!
Patricia B.California
View all testimonials
We spent the night here last night and we absolutely LOVE our place.  It is just gorgeous!  Every square inch of it is well thought out, beautiful, all the views; from lying in bed, from working, from cooking, all the window views, everything is just gorgeous. Thank you so much for your work.  Thanks for your help with colour choices;  it looks great!  You’ve done a fantastic job, I hope this piece is the highlight of your portfolio, or one of the highlights and brings you lots of work.  Its a … Read more
Sam R.Keats Island, BC
View all testimonials
John Gower Design has provided me with outstanding service, time after time. I have relied on his team’s ability to recognize the scope of work that I have required, and deliver exactly the level of service which I had asked for. John Gower Design has shown a high degree of experience on my projects that required design solutions. Many of the designs had high levels of difficulty and I was always impressed with the intuitive knowledge that I could tap into. A pleasure to work with!
Dave S. (Builder)Nelson, BC
View all testimonials
Everyone loves our plans and I have referred you to a number of people who are planning to build.
Zoltan & Jane K.Sakinaw Lake, BC
View all testimonials
I am thrilled with your work. I think the drawings look perfect.  I am very satisfied. It is, to me, a fantastic floor plan, and the exterior well achieves all of my design directives re: simplicity etc. Well done! All in all, I think the whole package is entirely excellent. Thank you for the great work.
Brian N.Procter, BC
View all testimonials

Let’s get started on your dream home.

We have the passion and the expertise
to make it a reality.

Contact Us Today!

212 - 2459 Cousins Avenue | Courtenay, British Columbia, Canada | V9N 3N6

Tel: 250.871.8765 | Toll-free: 1.877.366.2502

  • Facebook
  • Houzz

Copyright © 2021 John Gower Design